Is the Treadmill or Elliptical Better For Boosting Overall Fitness?

Treadmills and ellipticals are two extremely popular machines you can use at the gym or buy for your own home. And there's a reason for that: Both get your heart rate up, work your lower-body muscles, and get you moving in similar planes of motion (aka your feet are moving in the same direction: forward). So, on the surface, it'd stand to reason they're both pretty similar.

But is one cardio machine better than the other for boosting fitness and giving you an overall better workout? Or are they both equally as beneficial? To find out, we tapped two personal trainers for the pros and cons of each and how to figure out which one is best for you and your goals.

Experts in This Article

Or Artzi, CPT, is a certified personal trainer, lead group fitness instructor at Equinox, and creator of the fitness platform Orriors.

Noam Tamir, CSCS is a certified strength and conditioning specialist and founder and CEO of TS Fitness.

The Benefits of a Treadmill

The treadmill is a versatile and effective cardio machine that offers a controlled environment for walking and running, explains Or Artzi, CPT, lead group fitness instructor at Equinox and creator of the fitness platform Orriors. "It mimics natural movements that can translate into sports and other activities," adds Noam Tamir, CSCS, founder and CEO of TS Fitness.

A few notable perks of the treadmill, according to Artzi and Tamir, include:

The Drawbacks a Treadmill

While running or walking on the treadmill has its benefits, there are also a few downsides to consider, according to Artzi and Tamir. These include:

The Benefits of an Elliptical

The elliptical machine is a great option for people of all ability levels and you can get a full-body workout due to its mobile handles, Tamir explains. Here are a few more of the elliptical's benefits, according to Tamir and Artzi:

The Drawbacks of an Elliptical

While the elliptical offers an effective workout, it doesn't fully mimic natural walking or running mechanics, according to Artzi. "It's in a fixed position, so it's not very functional, and it minimizes muscle engagement," Tamir adds. What's more, this machine doesn't stimulate bone growth as much as weight-bearing activities like running, jumping, and resistance training, Artzi says.

Which Machine Is Right for You?

The treadmill may be the best option for you if you're a runner or walker looking to increase your heart health and bone and muscle strength, according to Tamir. It's a great option for runners getting ready for a race when getting outside isn't ideal or other athletes who need to train their endurance, he says.

On the other hand, you should avoid the treadmill — or use it cautiously with a doctor's approval — if you have knee, hip, or lower back injuries that worsen with impact, Artzi explains. Additionally, people who have cardiovascular issues and should avoid intense exercise, like running, should also opt for something other than the treadmill, Tamir says.

Choose the elliptical machine if you have knee injuries, arthritis, or joint pain, per Artzi. This is because the elliptical is low-impact in nature. Additionally, the elliptical is a great option if you're new to exercise or coming back after a long break, she says.

Worth noting: Athletes training for a specific sport — such as running, cycling, or swimming — may not want to use the elliptical because it's important to keep your training specific to your goals, Artzi explains. For instance, if you want to be a better runner, you'll need to focus on running. Those looking to maximize bone-strengthening benefits may need higher-impact activity, she adds.

Which Machine Is Better for Overall Fitness?

The treadmill burns more calories and builds more bone density than the elliptical, according to Tamir. The treadmill is also more functional than the elliptical because running and walking are more applicable to the real world than the motion of the elliptical is, he says. However, "the elliptical is better for people who need lower-impact exercise due to injuries and want to practice injury prevention," he says.

That being said, the "best" machine is the one you'll use the most and what works best for your goals and body, Artzi explains. "Both the treadmill and elliptical offer great benefits, but the most effective workout is the one where you can stay consistent and support your fitness goals," she says.

Danielle Zickl is a freelance writer who has 10 years of experience covering fitness, health, and nutrition. You can find her work here on PS and in many other publications, including Self, Well+Good, Runner's World, Outside Run, Peloton, Women's Health, and Men's Fitness.